What Now? policy on alternative and complementary therapies

9
Thomas - admin's picture
Thomas - admin

Hi guys.

We’ve put together some guidelines on what’s allowed and what isn’t on this site when talking about complementary and alternative therapies. To help you get your head around this, we’ve provided some examples of what’s ok and what isn’t, and tried to make our reasons clear. We will add this info to the Community guidelines so make sure you read it and understand it.

Since Macmillan Cancer Support is dedicated to providing high quality, expertly developed information about cancer, we have a duty to try to avoid members on this site posting information that may prove harmful to those who trust it.

If you come across anything that you think breaks these guidelines, please report it to us. Once notified, we may remove these posts and subsequent comments from the site. However, there may be occasions when we think that the replies provide valuable discouragement for people looking for information on that topic. We will close these threads and post an explanation.

Alternative therapies

What’s an alternative therapy?
An alternative therapy tries to treat cancer by unconventional methods instead of the usual medical treatment. Alternative therapies cannot cure cancer or control symptoms, and it is irresponsible to advise anybody not to follow conventional therapy or to ignore advice from their doctor or consultant.

When discussing alternative therapies, please do not:

  • Advocate the use of any alternative therapy.
  • Claim that any alternative therapy can cure cancer, reduce the size of tumours or in any way treat cancer
  • Advise anyone to ignore medical experts’ advice on the use of any treatment whatsoever
  • Advertise any alternative therapy for commercial gain. (No commercial solicitation is acceptable on the site)

When discussing alternative therapies, you may:

  • Provide anecdotal accounts about alternative therapy use, as long as you do not make unfounded claims about their effects

For example:

Not acceptable

Acceptable

“My friend took Essiac and it cured his cancer”

“I  took Essiac and it helped me with my pain”

“A friend of mine starting taking Essiac in May as well as carrying on with his radiotherapy. When I saw him in June, he said he was in less pain”

“The x diet can cure cancer”

“A balanced diet can help you to feel better about yourself”

“If your cancer can’t be cured the conventional way then there’s no harm in trying alternative therapies”

“You should always consult a medical specialist if you are thinking about using an alternative therapy” 

 

You should be aware that some therapies can be harmful and cause severe side effects. If you are thinking of trying an alternative therapy it is essential that you talk to your cancer doctor or cancer specialist nurse beforehand. If at any time you have any questions about an alternative therapy please::

 

Complementary therapies

What’s a complementary therapy?
A complementary therapy is one that is used alongside conventional treatments to improve quality of life. Complementary therapies do not influence the cancer itself but some can help to alleviate symptoms and the side effects of conventional treatments such as chemotherapy. Although some hospitals and hospices in the UK offer complementary therapies, this does not mean that they all have a positive effect, or that they are necessarily scientifically proven to control symptoms.

When discussing complementary therapies, please do not:

  • Advocate the use of any complementary therapy as an alternative to conventional treatment
  • Claim that any complementary therapy can cure cancer, reduce the size of tumours or in any way treat cancer
  • Advise anyone to ignore medical experts’ advice on the use of any treatment whatsoever
  • Advertise any complementary therapy for commercial gain. (No commercial solicitation is acceptable on the site)

When discussing complementary therapies, you may:

  • Advocate the use of complementary therapies in conjunction with conventional treatment
  • Make substantiated claims about the effectiveness of complementary therapies in improving quality of life

For example:

Not acceptable

Acceptable

“Hypnotherapy and meditation are more effective at treating cancer than chemo and radiotherapy”

“I’ve been having massage twice a week and I feel great”

“Faith healing has a positive physical effect”

“I believe that faith healing can help some people to feel better”

“Reiki can reduce the size of tumours”

“I tried reiki and it helped me to manage my pain”

“A diet of x is the reason I have never had cancer”

“A healthy diet of x has helped me feel stronger when faced with months of chemo”

 

If you have any questions at any time about complementary therapies:

Comments

Well done!

Dutchcloggie's picture

*claps hands enthusiastically*

Good policy with sensible examples. It leaves people space to talk about things in an informative way that does not mislead others.

What Now? policy

Thankyou Thomas. Very appropriate and very much appreciated!

Guide Lines

JacquiNZ's picture

Thank you for this very informative information. I must admit that I am not one to try alternative therapies as I prefer to down the conventional road for treatment. I have read the blogs regarding alternative/complimentary therapies and wondered whether they would be reliable.

Jacqui

Excellent!

seanty's picture

Fantastic news, should save me a lot of work! Thanks especially fro the clear-cut difference between complementary and alternative therapies, so often muddied by advocates.

There are lots of things we can do

Ruthless's picture

While I have been treated for cancer, totally on conventional lines - surgery and chemo, I have found many strategies helpful, and do not have any hesitation in recommending these to help with one's mood, and general wellbeing.

I would never recommend a strategy or therapy as an alternative to cancer treatment, but some people find various therapies helpful and beneficial when coping with side effects of treatment. If they feel that way, it is their right to use them, and to describe the effects they have experienced. We may have more or less the same illness, or group of illnesses, but we are individuals, and have a different response to treatments.

Some complementary therapies may not help, so it is wise to discuss the implications with one's medical advisers and be ready to stop the therapy if it is not helping.

Good one Thomas

carolb's picture

A much appreciated and succinct policy.
Carol x

Great

pusspins's picture

Thanks for the guidelines, Thomas.

well done

thank you thomas, with all the crackpots on here with proven vitamin D/yeast etc cures this is great guidelines and very much appreciated.

Welcome

pheonix's picture

I too welcome the guidelines and am glad there has been a seperation of ALTERNATIVE and COMPLEMENTARY therapies. They mean entirely different things. Unfortunately, without the amount of money that drug companies throw at new drug research there will never be the large scale studies of Complementary therapies to please the scientific world and until that day comes we are on an uneven play field.

Mistaken

seanty's picture

You are mistaken, pheonix. They are trialled. They just don't have any measurable effect. If they had an effect they would be medicine. Reiki for example does not have the effects you have claimed on here.

well done

jazzcat's picture

I'm sure the examples set out will indicate the correct wording to people when they wish to state their views and opinions. Let's hope this manages to get rid of some of the unpleasantness that appears to be on the increase.
Jazzcat

guidelines

sAngelapatt's picture

What a great job, thankyou.
Sincerely
Angela

thanks Thomas

Renee's picture

clearly constructed and defined - though in a lighter vein how hilarious that someone has to teach people to couch their statements appropriately.

Much as I admire seanty's research work and dedication - seanty - heading up threads saying "You're wrong" and "Mistaken" won't endear you to anyone really, but worse may make them skip your excellent input!!

Just my opinion!!!!

Alternative forums are

Alternative forums are available. ;)

But why?

seanty's picture

But why would you want to go somewhere else when the reliable information is here? Simply because the other forum allowed the promotion of quackery? What sort of sense does that make?